What would have happened if Harry was in Slytherin?

Plot-wise, having Harry be in Slytherin would have resulted in Dumbledore being much more aware of his connection to Voldemort. Harry’s determination to face Voldemort wouldn’t have changed if he had been in Slytherin because it wouldn’t have changed the fact that Voldemort killed his parents.

Would Harry have done well in Slytherin?

Harry Potter came very close to being sorted into Slytherin before he persuaded the Hat to sort him into Gryffindor. But Harry did share some Slytherin traits: he was ambitious and cunning, always sneaking around after hours and cooking up plans with Ron and Hermione. His green eyes even match the house.

What if Peter Pettigrew was a Slytherin?

Having placed Peter in Slytherin would have made the Marauder’s a trio, but the fact that it was Peter the rat who would freeze the willow, his absence would have led to no marauders at all, since they wouldn’t have the opportunity to roam around the village as easily without disabling the aggressive tree.

What if Snape was never sorted into Slytherin?

If Snape hadn’t been in Slytherin, Voldemort would have still risen to power, yes. But Snape might well have been on the good side from the start, and wouldn’t have betrayed Trelawney’s prediction to Lord Voldemort. Maybe the first wizarding war would have ended differently.

Does the Sorting Hat make mistakes?

Rumors have run rampant for years that there are 7 mistakes made by the Sorting Hat in the Harry Potter franchise, but creator J.K. Rowling maintains that the Hat never made a mistake.

How did a coward like Peter Pettigrew Gryffindor?

Peter Pettigrew got into Gryffindor, even though he was a coward, because he valued the traits of courage and chivalry. He wasn’t courageous or chivalrous, though, but he valued those traits and wanted to be like the big boys he admired. Plus, it helped that one could (in actuality), choose.

Was Dumbledore a Slytherin?

Dumbledore has strong traits of all four houses: he has greater brainpower than just about any Ravenclaw, he had the ambition and drive to excel as a Slytherin (which had tragic effects when combined with Grindelwald), he had an instinct for fairness towards the downtrodden that bespeaks a Hufflepuff, and he had the …

Has the Sorting Hat been wrong?

The Sorting Hat needed more than five minutes to decide whether Peter Pettigrew should be Sorted into Slytherin or Gryffindor. He was, thus, a true Hatstall. It chose Gryffindor. This decision was considered a mistake by many, though the Sorting Hat itself never considered it a mistake afterwards.

Would Snape have treated Harry better if he had been in Slytherin?

Snape treated Harry and the other students at Hogwarts terribly for many controversial reasons that could be discussed at length in the Harry Potter fandom. It’s difficult to say, though, whether he would treat Harry better or worse if he had been in Slytherin.

What would have happened if Harry Potter had been in Slytherin?

In short, Slytherin’s inner dynamics would have completely changed and there would probably have been a civil war within the house, as those loyal to Harry Potter clashed with the more traditionally evil students. Harry Potter would always be terrified of Severus Snape: he is a formidable character and his own Slytherin students fear him.

What was Harry’s relationship with Professor Snape like?

But as one of his own students, Harry may have had a far closer relationship with Snape, not least because being Sorted into Slytherin would challenge the Professor’s belief that Harry is ” just like his father.

What happened to Severus Snape and Lily Potter?

The pair were parted when the Sorting Hat placed Severus in Slytherin and Lily in Gryffindor, and while Lily thrived in her new, magical life, Snape was essentially placed in close quarters with the likes of Lucius Malfoy, Avery and Mulciber. Mulciber!