What are the two arguments about the 2nd Amendment?

First, that the proposed new Constitution gave the federal government almost total legal authority over the army and militia. Second, that the federal government should not have any authority at all to disarm the citizenry. They disagreed only about whether an armed populace could adequately deter federal oppression.

What right does the 2nd Amendment assure?

A well regulated Militia being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms shall not be infringed.

Which amendment is the most controversial?

The most controversial and most important part is the cruel and unusual punishment clause. The Eighth Amendment applies to criminal punishment and not to most civil procedures.

Are ‘Second Amendment sanctuaries’ forming in Virginia?

In the span of two months, more than 120 towns, cities, and counties in Virginia have declared themselves “Second Amendment sanctuaries” where “unconstitutional” gun laws would not be enforced.

Do Second Amendment sanctuary resolutions have a legal basis?

Mary B. McCord, a former acting assistant attorney general for national security, argued in The Washington Post that Second Amendment sanctuary resolutions have no legal basis and that only a court can overturn a state or federal law.

Do Gun sanctuary resolutions have any legal force?

Some officials who have passed gun sanctuary resolutions acknowledge that they don’t carry the force of law. The Board of Commissioners in Citrus County, Florida, said its resolution was a declaration of support for the Second Amendment and had no legal authority. “It’s not saying we won’t obey rules,” Commissioner Jimmie T. Smith said.

What is in a second amendment resolution?

The specific language used in Second Amendment resolutions varies from place to place. Some are more general declarations in support of Second Amendment rights, while others specify how a community will withhold support for state or federal gun laws.