What are the disadvantages of Federation in Australia?

CONS OF AUSTRALIAN FEDERATION

• Many feared cutting communications, cutting ties with England our mother country.
• States would believe that other states would have more power.
• Colonies may disagree with making Australia as a nation whilst the citizens within the state do agree.

Why was Victoria against Federation?

They encountered stiff opposition from the labour movement and others who thought the Australian Constitution being proposed for the new Commonwealth would not be democratic. The concern was that it would give too much power to States with smaller populations.

What were the arguments against Federation?

Arguments against Federation Federation would be expensive to achieve and a federated country would be expensive to run. The colonies had different policies about immigration, trade and other matters. Customs duties protected factories in the smaller colonies from goods made in factories in the larger colonies.

What are some disadvantages of Federation?

Federalism also comes with drawbacks. Chief among them are economic disparities across states, race-to-the-bottom dynamics (i.e., states compete to attract business by lowering taxes and regulations), and the difficulty of taking action on issues of national importance.

What were the arguments for and against Federation?

Some of the areas where people felt strongly for or against federation were: The capacity of a strong national government to manage issues such as trade, the economy, defence and immigration. The cost of setting up and running an Australian Parliament.

What are reasons against Federation?

What were some arguments for Federation?

“What were the arguments for and against federation?”

• The capacity of a strong national government to manage issues such as trade, the economy, defence and immigration.
• The cost of setting up and running an Australian Parliament.

What were some arguments against Federation?

Arguments against Federation All the colonies already had parliaments of their own. Federation would be expensive to achieve and a federated country would be expensive to run. The colonies had different policies about immigration, trade and other matters.

Why did many people oppose the Federation of Australia?

Firstly, many people opposed this idea, as there were many doubts and disadvantages to high and low status colonies. The more weaker and less wealthy states were worried that the more bigger states, like New South Wales and Victoria, would start controlling the country if Australia became a Federation.

What were the arguments in favour of the British Federation?

Arguments in favour of Federation 1 All the colonies were British and most white people spoke English. 2 School systems (which had begun in the 1880s) were teaching patriotic songs, stories and verses. 3 Many people moved between the colonies to find work. 4 Customs duties hindered trade between the colonies.

Why was New South Wales suspicious about joining the Federation?

This made New South Wales suspicious about joining a federation. As well, some people in New South Wales thought that since it was the oldest and largest colony, the other colonies should become part of New South Wales if they wanted to become one country.

Why didn’t Parkes lead Australia towards federation?

But at the same time, Parkes was losing the leadership of NSW and the issue of federation was no longer a top priority. Without the largest colony, the others could not proceed towards federation.